Usually, no. Once an agreement of purchase and sale is firm, a seller can’t cancel it just because they changed their mind, got a better offer, or decided the price was too low. A seller can end a deal only in limited situations, such as an unmet condition that protects the seller, a written release from the buyer, or the buyer’s own breach.
Here’s an example. Jack accepts an offer on his house. The next day, a second buyer offers $40,000 more. The first agreement has no conditions left, so it’s firm. If Jack walks away to take the higher offer, he breaches the contract, and the first buyer can take legal action. Jack can’t cancel just because a better deal appeared.
This guide explains when a seller can cancel, when they can’t, and what happens if they try.
When a seller can cancel
1. A condition in the seller’s favour isn’t met
Some agreements include conditions that protect the seller, such as a condition that the sale depends on the seller finding a new home. If the condition isn’t satisfied by its deadline, the agreement may end according to its own terms. The wording matters, so read the exact clause. In one 2025 Ontario case, the court ruled that an agreement became null and void on a set date and dismissed the buyer’s claim for specific performance.
2. Both sides sign a release
A buyer and seller can agree in writing to end the deal, usually through a mutual release. Nobody has to accept one. A buyer who wants the house can say no.
3. The buyer breaks the agreement
If the buyer isn’t ready to close on the closing date, the seller may have the right to end the deal. Generally, when a buyer isn’t ready, willing, and able to close on the closing date but the seller is, any deposit will be forfeited. See our article on what happens if your mortgage falls through before possession for the buyer’s side.
When a seller can’t cancel
A seller can’t cancel a firm agreement because:
They got a higher offer
They regret the price
They changed their mind about moving
The market went up after they signed
Asking for more money than the agreement says doesn’t help either. In one Ontario case, a seller who wanted to close for more than the agreed price made an unjustified demand, and the court called it an anticipatory breach of contract.
What the buyer can do if the seller backs out
When a seller refuses to close a firm agreement, the buyer can have contractual remedies. The main ones are:
Damages. A buyer may claim a supported difference between the contract price and the legally relevant market value. This is the most common remedy, and it requires proof of an actual financial loss.
Specific performance. The buyer asks a court to order the seller to complete the sale. Courts don’t grant this automatically. The buyer must show that damages are inadequate to make up for losing the property. In the 2025 case above, the court also found the buyer didn’t establish that the property was unique, so it denied this remedy.
A certificate of pending litigation. A court may authorize a certificate of pending litigation to be registered on title in litigation involving a legitimate claim to an interest in the land. It tells the world about the dispute, and it can stop the seller from selling to someone else while the case continues. It isn’t a final remedy, and it requires a court order and a legally supportable claim.
What it can cost a seller to back out
Damages to the buyer for their proven losses
Legal costs to defend a lawsuit, which can be high
A blocked sale, if the buyer registers a certificate of pending litigation
Commission. Your listing agreement may say you owe your agent’s commission even if the deal fails because of you. Read that clause, or ask your lawyer.
Fighting a dispute can also take months and delay your next move.
If you’re a seller thinking about backing out
Don’t go silent or ignore the buyer. A missed deadline or an unanswered letter can make your position worse.
Read your agreement. Check every condition, deadline, and closing date.
Talk to a lawyer before you act. Your options depend on the exact wording.
Ask about a release. If you have a real reason, a buyer may agree to end the deal, sometimes for a price.
Check your listing agreement and talk to your agent about commission.
If you’re a buyer and the seller goes quiet
Keep everything. Preserve your contract, your written communications, and proof that you’re ready to close.
Stay ready. Keep your financing and your documents in order.
Contact a lawyer promptly, because timing can matter for your remedies.
The bottom line
A signed, firm agreement is hard to cancel. A seller’s change of mind doesn’t count as a legal reason, and a seller who walks away risks damages, legal costs, and a blocked sale. If you’re considering it, get advice before you act. If you’re the buyer, protect your records and move quickly.
Questions about an agreement of purchase and sale? Contact us, and we’ll review your agreement and explain where you stand. If a dispute heads toward court, we’ll tell you plainly and help you find the right next step.
